Why did the ocarina develop a diverse playing tradition in Japan due to Sojiro, while ocarina playing in the West is much less diverse?

Why is it that Sojiro's playing of ocarina in Great Yellow River has lead to the development of a diverse playing tradition in Japan, whereas the use of the ocarina within the zelda games and people's exposure to them has not lead to the same kind of diversity in the West?

Many people that discovered the ocarina through Zelda seem to only be interested in playing zelda tunes. Some people explore video game and anime music more widely, but still few people appear to explore the full musical potential of the instrument.

On the surface these two situations, Sojiro exposing Japanese people to ocarinas, and Ocarina of Time exposing people in the West to ocarinas, are comparable. Both exposed the instrument to a large new audiance, but how they have played out are vastly different.

Presumably there were people adopting ocarinas for playing Sojiro's music verbitim in Japan, but something happened that caused an independant playing tradition to develop around the instrument, a tradition that is self-sustaining and stands alone from its originator.

In Japan there is large-scale instrument production, people composing new music for the ocarina, and professional highly skilled players and teachers. In the west, ocarina has mainly developed along a path of visual novelty and 'easy to play' marketing.

Edited 20-Jul-2026 11:35 AM by Robert.

Additional thoughts on this topic. Ocarinas were already being manufactured in Japan prior to Sojiro, and the instrument may have already had a serious playing tradition around it beforehand. If this is the case, then it would have been easy for the instrument to pick up in popularity.

In the west, the ocarina almost completely died out by the time that the Zelda game was released. Instruments started being produced after this time, such as by Songbird Ocarinas, however the general focus was on replicating the instrument from the game, less on playing the instrument well.